13 and Up AI Alasdair Stuart ann leckie Blog Computers Flashback Friday Flashback Fridays Ken Liu podcasts

Escape Pod 686: Real Artists (Flashback Friday)


Real Artists

by Ken Liu

“You’ve done well,” Artistic Director Len Palladon stated, wanting over Sophia’s résumé.

Sophia squinted in the golden California sun that fell on her by means of the large windows of the conference room. She needed to pinch herself to make certain she wasn’t dreaming. She was right here, actually right here, on the hallowed campus of Semaphore Footage, in an interview with the legendary Palladon.

She licked her dry lips. “I’ve always wanted to make movies.” She choked back for Semaphore. She didn’t need to seem too determined.

Palladon was in his thirties, dressed in a pair of snug shorts and a plain gray t-shirt whose entrance was coated with the drawing of a person swinging a large hammer over a railroad spike. A pioneer in computer-assisted film making, he had been instrumental in writing the corporate’s earliest software and was the director of The Mesozoic, Semaphore’s first movie.

He nodded and went on, “You won the Zoetrope screenwriting competition, earned excellent grades in both technology and liberal arts, and got great recommendations from your film studies professors. It couldn’t have been easy.”

To Sophia, he seemed a bit pale and tired, as if he had been spending all his time indoors, not out in the golden California solar. She imagined that Palladon and his animators should have been working additional time to satisfy a deadline: in all probability to complete the new movie scheduled to be launched this summer time.

“I believe in working hard,” Sophia stated. What she actually needed was to inform him that she knew what it meant to stay up all night time in entrance of the modifying workstation and watch for the rendering to finish, all for the prospect to catch the first glimpse of a imaginative and prescient coming to life on the display. She was ready.

Palladon took off his reading glasses, smiled at Sophia, and took out a tablet from behind him. He touched its display and slid it throughout the table to Sophia. A video was enjoying on it.

“There was also this fan film, which you didn’t put on your résumé. You made it out of footage cut and spliced from our movies, and it went viral. Several million views in two weeks, right? You gave our lawyers quite a headache.”

Sophia’s heart sank. She had all the time suspected that this may turn out to be an issue. However when the invitation to interview at Semaphore got here in her e-mail, she had whooped and hollered, and dared to consider that by some means the executives at Semaphore had missed that little movie.


Sophia remembered going to The Mesozoic. She was seven. The lights dimmed, her mother and father stopped talking, the primary few bars of Semaphore’s signature tune started to play, and she or he turned still.

Over the subsequent two hours, as she sat there in the dead of night theater, mesmerized by the journey of the digital characters on that display, she fell in love. She didn’t comprehend it then, however she would by no means love a person as much as she liked the company that made her cry and giggle, the company that made The Mesozoic.

A Semaphore film meant one thing: no, not merely technological prowess in digital animation and pc graphics that have been better than life. Positive, these accomplishments have been impressive, nevertheless it was Semaphore’s consistent potential to inform an excellent story, to make films with coronary heart, to entertain and move the six-year previous together with the sixteen-year previous and the sixty-year previous, that really made it an icon, a spot worthy of being liked.

Sophia noticed every of Semaphore’s films tons of of occasions. She bought them a number of occasions, in successive digital formats: discs, compressed downloads, lossless codecs, enhanced and re-enhanced and super-enhanced.

She knew each scene right down to the second, might recite every line of dialogue from memory. She didn’t even want the films themselves any more; she might play them in her head.

She took movie studies courses and commenced to make her personal shorts, and she or he yearned to make them feel as nice as the Semaphore classics. Advances in digital filmmaking gear made it potential for her to realize some spectacular results on a small finances. But regardless of how many occasions she rewrote her scripts or how late she stayed in the modifying labs, the results of her efforts have been laughable, embarrassing, ridiculous. She could not bear to observe them herself, a lot less present them to others.

“Don’t be discouraged,” a professor informed her, when he noticed her slumped over in despair. “You got into this because you wanted to make something beautiful. But it takes time, lots of time, to be good at any creative work. The fact that you hate your own work right now so much just means that you have good taste. And great taste is the most valuable tool of a great artist. Keep at it. Someday you’ll be as good as the best. Someday you’ll make something beautiful enough even for you.”

She went again to the Semaphore movies, picked them apart and put them back collectively, making an attempt to find their secret. Now she was not viewing them as a mere fan, however as a reverse-engineer.

Regularly, as a result of she did have great style, she could not assist however begin to see tiny flaws in them. The Semaphore movies weren’t fairly as good as she had thought. There have been small things here and there that could possibly be improved. And typically even massive things.

She went into seedy corners of the online to learn how to interrupt the encryption codes on her digital-rights-managed Semaphore film information, imported them into the modifying stations, and modified them to go well with her new vision.

After which she sat again within the darkness, at her pc, and watched her edited version of The Mesozoic once more. She cried when she was finished. It was better. She had made a fantastic movie even larger, closer to perfection.

Indirectly, she felt as if the right Semaphore movie had all the time been there, but hidden in locations beneath the veil that was the launched model. She had merely walked in and revealed the sweetness underneath.

How might she not share this vision with the world? She was in love with the great thing about Semaphore, and wonder needed to be free.


“I .. I …” Sophia realized now that she had been partaking in denial. She had refused to consider how she had possible broken the regulation just by putting that edited model on the internet. She had no good reply. “I love Semaphore’s movies so much …” Her voice trailed off.

Palladon held up a hand and laughed. “Relax. I think it was brilliant. I told the recruiting department to fly you out not because of your application or résumé, but because of your unauthorized re-edit.”

“You liked it?” Sophia might hardly consider her ears.

Palladon nodded. “Tell me what you think was your best change?”

Sophia did not hesitate. This question she had considered lots. “Semaphore’s films are wonderful, but they’re fantastic if you’re a boy. I changed The Mesozoic so that it was fantastic for girls too.”

Palladon stared at Sophia, deep in thought. Sophia held her breath.

“That makes sense,” Palladon lastly stated. “Most of us working here are men. I’ve been saying for years that we need more women in the process. I was right about you: a real artist will do whatever it takes to make a great vision come true, even if she has to work with someone else’s art.”


“All done?”

Sophia nodded and handed the stack of signed authorized documents back to Palladon. He had explained that earlier than he might give her a suggestion, he needed to point out her a little bit of the Semaphore artistic process so she would know what she was moving into. She had to sign some fairly draconian NDAs to protect Semaphore’s commerce secrets and techniques.

Sophia didn’t hesitate for even one second. Getting a peek at how Semaphore made its magic was a lifelong dream.

Palladon took her down an extended collection of hallways lined with closed doorways. Sophia appeared round, imagining what lay behind them: shiny, open workspaces where every worker was free to embellish her cubicle to precise her creativity? Legendary convention rooms full of colorful Lego blocks and Japanese toys to get the artistic juices of the artists and engineers flowing? Server rooms crammed with the proprietary computing hardware that made all of the magic potential? Artistic, gifted artists reclining in bean bag chairs tossing around the germ of an concept, every including and sprucing until it shone full and lustrous as a pearl?

The doors remained closed.

Lastly, Palladon stopped in entrance of a door and unlocked it with a key. He and Sophia walked into the darkness past.


They have been within the projection booth overlooking a small theater. Sophia seemed via the booth window and counted about sixty seats under, about half of which have been crammed. The viewers was utterly absorbed by the movie enjoying on the large display in front. The buzzing from the projectors crammed the booth.

“Is that … ?” Sophia pressed her nostril up towards the window. Her heart pounded in her ears. She forgot to complete the question.

“Yes,” Palladon stated. “That’s an early version of our next film: The Mesozoic Again. It’s a story about a boy meeting a dinosaur, and learning timeless lessons about friendship and family.”

Sophia watched the brilliant figures on the display, wishing she have been down there, among the rapt audience.

“So this is a test screening?”

“No, this is how the film is made.”

“I don’t understand.”

Palladon walked over to a bank of shows on the other aspect of the projection booth and pulled out two chairs. “Sit down. I’ll explain.”

The screens showed bundles of strains of various colors shifting slowly throughout the display, like the strains traced by heart screens or seismographs.

“You know, of course, that a movie is an intricate emotion-generating machine.”

Sophia nodded.

“During the span of two hours, it must lead the audience by the nose on an emotional rollercoaster: moments of laughter are contrasted with occasions for pity, exhilarating highs followed by terrifying and precipitous drops. The emotional curve of a film is its most abstract representation as well as the most primal. It’s the only thing that lingers in the audience’s mind after they leave the theater.”

Sophia nodded once more. This was all simply primary film concept.

“So how do you know that the audience is following the curve you want?”

“I guess you do what every storyteller does,” Sophia stated, hesitant, feeling lost. “You try to empathize with the audience.”

Palladon waited, his expression unchanged.

“And maybe you try to do test screenings and tweak things a bit at the end,” Sophia added. Truly she didn’t consider in check screenings. She thought focus teams and viewers reaction surveys have been why the other studios produced such pap. But she didn’t know what else to say.

“Aha,” Palladon stated, clapping his arms together. “But how do you get test audiences to give you useful feedback? If you survey them after, you’ll only get very crude answers, and people lie, telling you what they think you want to hear. If you try to get people to give real-time feedback by pressing buttons as they watch the film, they become too self-conscious, and people aren’t always good at understanding their own emotions.”


Sixty cameras have been suspended from the ceiling of the theater, every educated on a single seat under.

As the movie performed, the cameras relayed their feeds to a financial institution of highly effective computers, where every feed was put via a collection of pattern-recognition algorithms.

By detecting microscopic shifts in every face brought on by the enlargement and contraction of blood vessels under the pores and skin, the computers monitored every audience member’s blood strain, pulse, and degree of pleasure.

Different algorithms tracked the expressions on each face: smiling, smirking, crying, impatience, annoyance, disgust, anger, or simply boredom and apathy. By measuring how much sure key factors on a face moved — corners of the mouth, the eyes, ends of eyebrows — the software program might make superb distinctions, like that between a smile out of amusement and a smile as a consequence of affection.

The info, collected in real time, might be plotted towards every frame of the film, displaying every audience member’s emotional curve as they experienced the film.


“So you can tune your movies a little better than other studios with test screenings. Is that your secret?”

Palladon shook his head. “Big Semi is the greatest auteur in the history of filmmaking. It doesn’t just ‘tune.’”


Greater than seven thousand processors have been wired together into a computing grid within the basement of the Semaphore campus. This was the place Huge Semi — the “semi” was brief for either “semiotics” or “semantics,” no one knew for positive any extra — lived. Massive Semi was The Algorithm, Semaphore’s actual secret.

Each day, Huge Semi generated kernels for high-concept films by randomly choosing out seemingly incongruous ideas out of a database: cowboys and dinosaurs, WWII techniques in area, a submarine movie transposed onto Mars, a romantic comedy starring a rabbit and a greyhound.

Within the palms of less-skilled artists, these concepts would have gone nowhere, but Massive Semi, based mostly on Semaphore’s report, had entry to the emotional curves of confirmed hits in each genre. It might use these as templates.

Taking the high-concept kernel, Massive Semi generated a rough plot using extra random parts taken from a database of basic films augmented with trending memes in the zeitgeist gathered from net search statistics. It then rendered a rough film based mostly on that plot, utilizing inventory characters and inventory dialogue, and screened the outcome for a check viewers.

The preliminary attempt was often laughably dangerous. The viewers response curves can be in all places, however nowhere near the goal. But that was no huge deal for Huge Semi. Nudging responses to fit a recognized curve was nothing greater than an optimization drawback, and computer systems have been excellent at those.

Massive Semi turned artwork into engineering.

Say that the beat at ten minutes in must be a second of poignancy. If the hero saving a nest of child dinosaurs didn’t do it, then Massive Semi would substitute in a scene of the hero saving a household of furry proto-otters and see if the response curves on the subsequent check screening moved any nearer to the perfect.

Or say that the joke that ended act one wanted to get the viewers into a specific temper. If a variation on a line taken from a basic didn’t do it, then Huge Semi would attempt a popular culture reference, a bodily gag, and even change the scene into an impromptu musical quantity — a few of these options have been issues no human director would ever consider — but Massive Semi had no preconceptions, no taboos. It will attempt all options and decide the perfect one based mostly on outcome alone.

Huge Semi sculpted actors, built sets, framed photographs, invented props, refined dialogue, composed music, and devised special effects — all digitally, in fact. It treated every thing as levers to nudge the response curves.

Progressively, the inventory characters got here to life, the inventory dialogue gained wit and pathos, and a murals emerged from random noise. On common, after 100 thousand iterations of this course of, Huge Semi would have a movie that elicited from the audience the specified emotional response curve.

Huge Semi didn’t work with scripts and storyboards. It didn’t give any thought to themes, symbols, homages, or another phrases you may discover in a film research syllabus. It didn’t complain of having to work with digital actors and digital units as a result of it knew of no different method. It simply evaluated every check screening to see the place the response curves nonetheless deviated from the goal, made massive modifications and small tweaks and tested it once more. Massive Semi did not assume. It had no pet political cause, no personal history, no narrative obsession or idée fixe that it needed to push into its films.

Certainly Massive Semi was the right auteur. Its only concern was to create an artifact as meticulously crafted as a Swiss watch that exactly pulled the viewers along the precise emotional curve assured to make them snort and cry in the appropriate places. After they left the theater, they might give the film great word-of-mouth, the one form of advertising that worked persistently, that all the time obtained by way of individuals’s ad-blockers.

Huge Semi made good movies.


“So what would I do”? Sophia asked. She felt her face flush and her coronary heart beating quick. She questioned if any cameras have been in the sales space, observing her. “What do you do? It sounds like Big Semi is the only creative one around here.”

“Why, you’ll be a member of the test audience, of course,” Palladon stated. “Isn’t that obvious? We can’t let the secret out, and Big Semi requires audiences to do its work.”

“You just sit there all day and watch movies? You can do that with anybody off the street!”

“No, we can’t,” Palladon stated. “We do need some non-artists in the audience to be sure we’re not out of touch, but we need even more people with great taste. Some of us have much more knowledge about the history of film, finer senses of empathy, broader emotional ranges, more discerning eyes and ears for details, deeper capacities for feeling — Big Semi needs our feedback to avoid trite clichés and cheap laughs, mawkish sentiment and insincere catharsis. And as you’ve already discovered on your own, the composition of the audience determines how good a film Big Semi can make.”

I’ve been saying for years that we’d like extra ladies in the process.

“It is only by trying out his skill against the finest palate that a chef can design the best dishes. Big Semi needs the best audience to make the best film the world has ever seen.”

And nice taste is probably the most invaluable device of a fantastic artist.


Sophia sat numbly in the conference room, alone.

“Are you all right?” A secretary passing by poked her head in.

“Yes. I just need a moment.”

Palladon had explained to her that there can be eye drops and facial massages to combat the bodily fatigue. There would even be medicine to induce short-term memory loss so that everyone might overlook the film that they had just seen and sit by means of the subsequent screening again, tabulae rasae. The forgetting was needed to ensure that Massive Semi received correct feedback.

Palladon had gone on to say many different issues, however Sophia didn’t keep in mind any of them.

So that is what it’s wish to fall out of affection.


“You have to let us know within two weeks,” Palladon stated, as he walked Sophia down the long driveway to the campus gate.

Sophia nodded. The drawing on the front of Palladon’s t-shirt caught her consideration. “Who is that?”

“John Henry,” Palladon stated. “He was a laborer on the railroads in the nineteenth century. When the owners brought in steam-powered hammers to take jobs away from the driving crews, John challenged a steam hammer to a race to see who could work faster.”

“Did he win?”

“Yes. But as soon as the race was over, he died of exhaustion. He was the last man to challenge the steam hammers because the machines got faster every year.”

Sophia stared at the drawing. Then she appeared away.

Hold at it. Someday you’ll be nearly as good as the perfect.

She would by no means be nearly as good as Massive Semi, who obtained better every year.

The golden California sun was so vibrant and warm, however Sophia shivered.

She closed her eyes and remembered how she felt in that darkish theater as just a little woman. She was transported to another world. That was the point of great artwork. Watching an ideal film was like dwelling an entire different life.

“A real artist will do whatever it takes to make a great vision come true,” Palladon stated, “even if it’s just sitting still in a dark room.”